Feasibility Study and the Business Plan are critical in determining the viability of such ventures which are risk filled.
Policy Influence
None.
Emphasis on Sustainable Livelihoods
The emphasis of the project at this stage is to determine what form of recycling will be viable to address environmental impacts while also creating employment and income.
Planning gef grant
To be determined.
Planning non gef grant
To be determined.
Project sustainability
Will be determined after the grantee has proceeded with the project implementation phase.
Project Results
The project (Planning Grant) was funded to determine the feasibility of establishing a profitable recycling plant in Saint Lucia. The project proceeded in two basic stages as follows: (i) A Feasibility Study; and (ii) The preparation of a Business Plan.
The feasibility study examined the need for a recycling plant in Saint Lucia; sources of recyclable material; the categories of waste and the percentages of each category as part of the national waste stream; the external markets; the best location for the facility; and the most cost effective means of collecting the waste. The study also looked at three options for establishing the facility as follows: (i) Lease and operate the facility at XCD$3000 (US$1111) per month; (ii) Construct and operate a facility; and (iii) Public/Private Partnership between the SLBWA (grantee) and the Saint Lucia Solid Waste management Authority. The Results were as follows: Option 1 had an IRR of 2.16%; Option 2: 4.28%; and Option 3: 18.36%. The study concluded that the recycling market in Saint Lucia was large enough for an additional processing plant and that the most viable option was for a Public Private Partnership. (Title of Study: Feasibility Study for a Material Recovery Facility - Prepared for the Saint Lucia Blind Welfare Association with Funding Assistance from the GEF Small Grants Programme - Prepared by BEEQ Inc.).
The Business Plan concluded that the grantee should establish a Limited Liability Company called the SLBWA Recycling Ltd and that the main keys to success were as follows: (i) Secure Supply- Contract for supply of post-consumer bottles and other recyclables; (ii) Effective Public Education and Awareness to change behaviour, expand the market and increase share of the market; (iii) Marketing - Contractual arrangements for the sale of virtually all initial production. (iv) Management - Strong senior management with extensive, broad-based, industry-specific experience; (v) Support from the GOSL through the SLSWMA; and (vi) Support from other donor agencies.
The business plan also outlined the potential risk as follows: (i) Unavailable or scarce raw material feed stock for production; (ii) Technology employed may be unreliable; (iii) There may not be a market for the Company's products; (iv) The location where markets exists are distant and have high shipping cost; (v) The Company may not be able to attract capable management; (vi) Company may not meet environmental standards; (vii) The Company may not be able to sell all of its production capability; and (viii) The Company may not be able to obtain the required funds at a reasonable cost to make the venture viable. (Title of Business Plan: Business Plan for Recycling Facility for the Saint Lucia Blind Welfare Association Recycling Company Limited - Funded by SLBWA and GEF SGP UNDP. - Prepared by BEEQ Inc.).
The Planning Grant proved that establishing a recycling operation was feasible but required knowledgeable and skilled individuals with a significant start-up capital, estimated at XCD$642,470 (US$237,952), and that the least cost method was a Public Private Partnership.
Lessons Learned by the Grantee:
They included the following: (i) Cast a very wide net to attract as many consultants/facilitators as possible and depend less on recommendations - the grantee strongly believes that the mass media should have been used in that process; (ii) Include a penalty clause in the contract to reduce the delays in reporting by the consultants/facilitators; and (iii) Undertake more detailed planning to avoid being overly ambitious with the workplan.